Google Rating
5.0
Based on 484 reviews
js_loader
Click to Quote
A Florida Insurance Plan Made Just For You
Get the coverage you need at the most competitive rates in Florida.
Get A Quote Now
Man with umbrella - Live Covered
Everyone Deserves To Live Covered.™

A lot of people have insurance plans that don’t actually fit their needs, which means they are either overpaying or are improperly covered. At Cornerstone Insurance, we take the time to get to know you first and then put together an insurance plan that actually fits. That way, you get the most value out of every dollar and get the coverage you need without overpaying.

Click to Quote

5-Star Florida Insurance Agency

★★★★★

Cornerstone Insurance, Inc. is an independently owned and operated Trusted Choice® personal lines insurance agency serving Floridians across the state including Tampa, Orlando, Ocala, Jacksonville, Gainesville, the Panhandle and all the towns and cities in between. Our independent Florida insurance agency offers a one-channel insurance solution for Florida residents. We represent more than 20 insurance carriers offering condo / homeowners insurance, flood insurance, auto insurance, umbrella insurance, boat / ATV / RV insurance, and more.

And, because we are an independent insurance agency, we offer our clients the best carriers, at the best premiums and with the service, diligence and professionalism they deserve. Real people, forming real relationships, is at the heart of Cornerstone Insurance’s mission.
Meet our team →

Joshua Butts, owner
Mara Koogle
Karen Aragon
Joshua Gleaton
James Bonn
Eric Bushey
Kim Glowiak
Gina McNairy
Kyle Wilson
Jamie Piralta

3 Easy Steps to Better Coverage

Step 1

Request A Quote

Because we take the time to get to know you and ask the right questions, we’re able to put together a quote that fits you best, so you don’t overpay for your insurance.

Step 2

Review Your Options

As an independent insurance agency, we are able to work with a wider number of providers than most agencies, so you get the best value for your policy.

Step 3

Breathe Easy!

We’ll walk you through the whole process, help you cancel your previous coverage, and are here for you whenever your insurance needs change.

Click to Quote

Here's What Our Clients Have to Say

js_loader
READ MORE REVIEWS

Reliable Personal Insurance Florida Residents Can Depend On

Looking for affordable and dependable auto, homeowners, renters, flood, motorcycle, or umbrella insurance? Florida residents can count on the companies we work with to give you the coverage you need at a price you can afford. 

We assist you in finding a carrier that has strong financial ratings, extensive claims-paying experience, and great customer service. As a result, we partner with respected carriers like Tower Hill, Travelers, Safeco, Progressive, Mercury, Olympus, Florida Peninsula, Edison, Heritage,  American Integrity Insurance, and more.

Get A Quote Now

Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Insurance Coverage

At Cornerstone we take pride in custom fitting a group of policies for the needs and desires of each client. We understand that people have different needs based on their unique situation. We leverage our relationships with many carriers to tailor a policy plan that will give you the coverage you need at a price that fits your budget.

We are a proud member of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents, the Trusted Choice® Insurance Network and an A+ rated Accredited Member of the Better Business Bureau®. And, we have hundreds of 5-star reviews spanning more than a decade.

Cornerstone Insurance Inc. Better Business Bureau logo and A+ rating

Call or text us today at (813) 920-8181 or fill out our form to request a free homeowners insurance quote. We appreciate your business and look forward to serving you.

Cornerstone’s carriers provide a comprehensive range of personal insurance products for Florida residents, including:

Because we are independent, we offer our clients the best insurance carriers, at the best premiums and with the service, diligence and professionalism you deserve. We represent more than 40 carriers, including:

  • American Integrity Insurance
  • Tower Hill Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Heritage Insurance
  • Federated National Insurance
  • Florida Peninsula
  • Edison Insurance
  • United Property and Casualty
  • Universal Property and Casualty
  • Hudson Insurance
  • Travelers Insurance
  • Mercury Insurance
  • Mapfre Insurance
  • Safeco Insurance
  • Safepoint Insurance
  • And More
Debbie H.
Finding good, reliable homeowners insurance in the state of Florida is not an easy task for a homeowner these days, especially if you have an older home.
Having been with the same company for over 25 years I felt overwhelmed at the thought of trying to find the right fit for us again.
Eric Bushey at Cornerstone Insurance made such an impression on myself and my husband, he was truly a pleasure to deal with.
He answered all of our questions (for many days) made suggestions, helpful ideas, and was so kind & patient with us.

Thank you Eric and Cornerstone Insurance!
Andrew P.
Amazingly helpful. Very responsive. Highly recommend!!!
Susan T.
I worked with James Boon at Cornerstone and he did a great job reducing our home insurance and better coverage. He was a pleasure to work with and very responsive. Highly recommend.
Jeff K.
My goal when I first contacted Cornerstone Insurance Company was to lower my Car Insurance rates and my Home Owners Insurance rates. With the help of Agent Josh Gleaton i was able to accomplish that goal. Josh is very kind and courteous! Most importantly he is so knowledgable about the insurance industry! Personally, I felt like he was on my side! I was formally with the same company for 51 years! Honestly, they priced themselves out of what my wife and I could afford. The two companies I chose were because they are both highly rated! Josh gave me many choices. With his expertise and knowledge I was able to pick two great companies and literally save thousands of dollars a year with both policies! I might add without sacrificing one thing vs the other company I had. Actually, my car insurance deductible came down to 250.00 and my homeowners detectable went from 10% for the hurricane deductible to 2%. Anyway, call and ask for Josh Gleaton and he might be able to help you as he was able to help me! Totally, a 5 Star Company and Josh makes it easy and he’s a total gentleman!
Cynthia L.
Eric Bushey was awesome, I'm very pleased with how he treated me and how quickly he got things done! If I could give him more stars I would.
js_loader