An Auto Insurance Plan Made Just For You
Get the coverage you need for your vehicle at a price you can afford.
Man driving with father in an insured vehicle
Everyone Deserves To Live Covered.™

A lot of people have auto insurance plans that don’t actually fit their needs, which means they are either overpaying or are undercovered. At Cornerstone Insurance, we take the time to get to know you first and then put together a plan that actually fits. That way, you get the most value out of every dollar and get the vehicle coverage you need without overpaying.

5-Star Tampa Auto Insurance Company

★★★★★

Looking for auto insurance Tampa residents can count on? Cornerstone Insurance is here to help. We are a family-owned and operated Trusted Choice® independent personal lines insurance agency serving Floridians in Tampa, Orlando, Ocala, Jacksonville and many towns and cities in between. Our independent Tampa agency offers a one channel insurance solution for Florida residents. 

Because we are independent, we offer our clients many of the top A rated car, truck, minivan and SUV insurance carriers in the state, at the best premiums and with the service, diligence and professionalism they deserve. 

Trusted Choice logo
Cornerstone Insurance, Inc. Better Business Bureau logo and A+ rating
3 Easy Steps to Better Coverage
Step 1

Get A Quote

Because we take the time to get to know you and ask the right questions, we’re able to put together a quote that fits you best, so you don’t overpay for your car insurance.

Step 2

Review Your Options

As an independent insurance agency, we are able to work with a wider number of providers than most agencies, so you get the best value for your policy.

Step 3

Breathe Easy!

We’ll walk you through the whole process, help you cancel your previous coverage, and are here for you whenever your insurance needs change.

Here's What Our Clients Have to Say

Excellent
Cornerstone Insurance Inc.
Based on 527 reviews
Cindy R.
Eric was a lifesaver. I called him in a panic after yet again our homeowners insurance almost tripled in Tampa, so of course I start looking to find cheaper and one phone call is all it took. He went into action and took over and got me an amazing rate. He was patient and answered any questions I had and eased my mind and told me he'd help me no matter what. I will now recommend Eric to everyone I know whose insurance yet again went up.
Deborah H.
I needed to contact this company along time ago. I can't say enough about Kyle Wilson. He responded to my texts, emails and phone calls promptly. A rarity in the business world today. He got me the best deal on my homeowners insurance and I had called around myself. I highly recommend Kyle and Cornerstone!
ArtwithJanal K.
I had to give 4 stars because in the end they couldn’t help me, but Josh got back to me immediately with answers to my questions. Very helpful and friendly. Thanks for your knowledge and understanding.
Marlene H.
We have been searching for a more affordable homeowners insurance policy and we got a quick response from James Bonn at cornerstone insurance. The quote we got was much lower than other insurers and after a home inspection, we were insured by Tower Hill. He walked us through the whole process and we are good to go. In 6 months we will be checking back with James for our auto insurance.
Barbara T.
Gina McNairy gets an “A” in customer service. She patiently explained insurance details that she had already explained to my husband. She further was very patient in explaining how Docusign works, sometimes patiently explaining things twice. I know she had a heavy workload awaiting her when she finished our phone call.She continued being patient throughout the call.
John D.
Fast easy and knowledgeable
Tami M.
Our agent, James Bonn, was very nice to work with and stayed connected throughout the process. We had the quotes the same day which he thoroughly reviewed with us and answered all of our questions.
Adam R.
Cornerstone came in clutch when my existing insurance cancelled my policy due to a discrepancy from the inspection report. I reached out to Cornerstone through their website, and in just a couple of days, Eric Bushey set me up with a policy that offered more coverage for a lesser price than what I purchased when I first bought the property. I'm actually shocked they made it this easy. Highly recommend!
Michael V.
Gina and everyone at Cornerstone are great people to work with.
Dayana L.
Kyle Wilson was our agent and he was incredibly helpful at getting us the best quote for our home. Really happy with his customer service!! Good people
Shane N.
Cornerstone helped me with my new house and was very upfront and honest. Kyle Wilson exhibited patience with me and answered all my questions.
colette O.
Gina McNairy was wonderful to work with, and she gets another 5-star rating for her patience!! I had many phone calls and questions, and she excelled at explaining all of it.
Miguel R.
Gina McNairy was very helpful, thorough and very professional. She communicated extremely well from the beginning and through the end. Provided excellent options and explained the alternative. Finally, she interacted very effectively with the Realtor and the Loan Officer to ensure that all transactions were carried forward. Highly Recommended.
Michael G.
Eric is a first class representative who professionally anticipates issues and so patiently explains the tiny details. He is just really really good and a joy to work with.
john G.
Eric Bushey is the best, always fast and curious service.

Car Insurance Options in Florida

When searching for personal auto insurance, Tampa FL residents have many choices, but finding the right car insurance policy for your individual needs can be a challenge. Many insurance agents in the Tampa area are exclusive to only one carrier. But when choosing Cornerstone to provide your auto insurance, Tampa auto owners will receive multiple coverage quotes from multiple highly rated companies like Progressive, Travelers, Mercury Insurance Group and many others. These are companies that have a proven track record of reliability and affordability. 

Frequently Asked Questions About Auto Insurance

Many people wonder if they really need auto insurance. Tampa drivers should be aware that if you own a vehicle, it is the law that you have at least the state minimums of PIP (Personal Injury Protection) and property damage liability. If your car has a loan, the finance company may also require collision insurance until the loan is paid off. Here are some other reasons why it is wise to carry auto insurance:

  • If your motor vehicle is ever stolen or totaled in an accident, it will cost a lot of money to replace it without insurance.
  • If you are ever in an accident where you or other passengers sustain injury, you may be held liable for the medical costs.
  • If your vehicle ever causes damage or serious injury to others, you could be sued for far more than your net worth.

That depends on your individual situation. You only “need” to carry what the state and/or your financial institution requires. However, it is best to have enough coverage to protect you and your family. When considering the amount of coverage needed for auto insurance, Tampa Florida drivers should also consider the following:

  • What can you afford to pay out of pocket in the event of an auto accident? If you can afford to pay more for possible repairs, then you may want to choose a policy with a higher deductible, saving you money on your premiums.
  • Does your car have a loan against it? If the answer is yes, you will probably be required to carry collision car insurance.
  • What is your total financial worth? You will want your liability limits to equal or exceed your total net worth. This will protect you and your family from a lawsuit. If your net worth is higher than the maximum liability limit on the auto insurance, you may want to consider an umbrella policy.

Because we are independent, we offer our clients the best carriers, at the best premiums and with the service, diligence and professionalism you deserve. We represent many of the top car, truck and SUV insurance carriers, including Progressive Insurance, Travelers Insurance, Mercury Insurance, Mapfre Insurance, and Safeco Insurance.

Cindy R.
Eric was a lifesaver. I called him in a panic after yet again our homeowners insurance almost tripled in Tampa, so of course I start looking to find cheaper and one phone call is all it took. He went into action and took over and got me an amazing rate. He was patient and answered any questions I had and eased my mind and told me he'd help me no matter what. I will now recommend Eric to everyone I know whose insurance yet again went up.
Deborah H.
I needed to contact this company along time ago. I can't say enough about Kyle Wilson. He responded to my texts, emails and phone calls promptly. A rarity in the business world today. He got me the best deal on my homeowners insurance and I had called around myself. I highly recommend Kyle and Cornerstone!
ArtwithJanal K.
I had to give 4 stars because in the end they couldn’t help me, but Josh got back to me immediately with answers to my questions. Very helpful and friendly. Thanks for your knowledge and understanding.
Marlene H.
We have been searching for a more affordable homeowners insurance policy and we got a quick response from James Bonn at cornerstone insurance. The quote we got was much lower than other insurers and after a home inspection, we were insured by Tower Hill. He walked us through the whole process and we are good to go. In 6 months we will be checking back with James for our auto insurance.
Barbara T.
Gina McNairy gets an “A” in customer service. She patiently explained insurance details that she had already explained to my husband. She further was very patient in explaining how Docusign works, sometimes patiently explaining things twice. I know she had a heavy workload awaiting her when she finished our phone call.She continued being patient throughout the call.