Cornerstone Insurance Inc.

Established 2009 | Florida

Cornerstone Insurance, Inc. is an independently owned-and-operated insurance agency founded by native Floridians. 

Core Values: honesty, integrity, professionalism, diligence and respect for our clients, fellow employees, business partners, and community.

Our Mission

To our clients:

To inspire faith and confidence in all we do, to provide value in the marketplace by offering quality and affordable insurance products through a choice of financially stable companies, to provide professional, timely and accurate client service, to build long lasting mutually beneficial relationships built on our core values and to become the insurance agency of choice for our target market.

To our employees:

To create a company culture where employees are respected, appreciated and valued, afforded the tools and training to be successful, to carry out our mission while emulating our core values, to create a positive and rewarding environment where team work is emphasized and efficiency and productivity are rewarded, and to offer industry competitive compensation for their valuable contributions.

To our business partners / companies:

To be a trusted, reliable and long term business partner, to write quality, mutually profitable business that will support the financial well being of our carriers and to work together to provide the best experience possible for our mutual clients.

To our community:

To invest in our community by contributing our time and financial resources, to promote and support family and country, and to be seen as a good corporate citizen operating with the highest regard for all our stakeholders.

Meet Our Team

Joshua Butts, Florida insurance agency owner

Joshua Butts

Owner - Team Leader - Licensed Agent in Charge
Cornerstone Insurance agent professional photo

Mara Koogle

Leader of Account Management, Licensed Advisor
Karen Aragon

Karen Aragon

Welcome Team Leader. Licensed Account Manager

Kari Tate

Licensed Advisor
Kyle Wilson - Cornerstone Insurance agent Tampa FL

Kyle Wilson

Licensed Advisor
Cornerstone Insurance logo

Laura Litchy

Licensed Advisor
James Bonn - Cornerstone Insurance agent Florida

James Bonn

Licensed Advisor
Josh Gleaton - Cornerstone Insurance agent Tampa FL

Joshua Gleaton

Licensed Advisor
Cornerstone Insurance Google rating screenshot

Claire Arevalo

Welcome Team Associate
Jamie Piralta - Cornerstone Insurance agent Florida

Jamie Piralta

Agency Administration

Why Cornerstone?

Florida’s insurance market is unlike anywhere else in the country. Rising premiums, carrier exits, and reduced coverage options have left too many homeowners, drivers, and families without the protection they actually need.

We’re selective about the carriers we work with. Cornerstone partners only with companies that have proven experience operating in Florida — or newer carriers backed by highly experienced management teams. We don’t chase volume. We specialize in building comprehensive, customized coverage packages around the real-life situations our clients face every day.

Cornerstone is a proud member of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents and the Trusted Choice Insurance Network, and holds an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau. We focus exclusively on personal lines insurance — because doing one thing well means our clients always get our full attention.

Cornerstone Insurance, Inc. Better Business Bureau logo and A+ rating
Trusted Choice logo

Here's What Our Clients Have to Say

Excellent
Cornerstone Insurance Inc.4.9
Based on 604 reviews
Kari Metzger
3 days ago
Jame did a awesome job in getting us placed with a new hoeowners policy on very short notice after our existing policy got non-renewed. He was prompt, efficient, friendly and courteous and got the job done! I would highly recommend him!
Kari Metzger
3 days ago
Jame did a awesome job in getting us placed with a new hoeowners policy on very short notice after our existing policy got non-renewed. He was prompt, efficient, friendly and courteous and got the job done! I would highly recommend him!
Nancy Benoit
6 days ago
Prompt response to your inquiry
Nancy Benoit
6 days ago
Prompt response to your inquiry
Joseph Pestello
1 week ago
James did an outstanding job taking over my Home and Auto policies. He is very knowledgeable and quickly quoted both policies. I would highly recommend him!
Joseph Pestello
1 week ago
James did an outstanding job taking over my Home and Auto policies. He is very knowledgeable and quickly quoted both policies. I would highly recommend him!
Ms. Patty
3 weeks ago
Mr. James Bonn, was quick to response, heard my needs and adjusted my policy quote to fit them. Respected my time and style of communication. I am very appreciative of the way he handled the whole process, from the sales to closing the deal.
Ms. Patty
3 weeks ago
Mr. James Bonn, was quick to response, heard my needs and adjusted my policy quote to fit them. Respected my time and style of communication. I am very appreciative of the way he handled the whole process, from the sales to closing the deal.
Katie Burris
3 weeks ago
Very friendly, prompt and courteous service and they were able to provide me with an awesome rate for my insurance needs. Kari was fabulous!
Katie Burris
3 weeks ago
Very friendly, prompt and courteous service and they were able to provide me with an awesome rate for my insurance needs. Kari was fabulous!
Mike Rixon
4 weeks ago
James was great. It was very easy to switch my auto insurance over and saved a lot of money.
Mike Rixon
4 weeks ago
James was great. It was very easy to switch my auto insurance over and saved a lot of money.
Candace Hagedorn
4 weeks ago
Excellent service. Kari is wonderful. Should I move forward, I will reach out to her.
Candace Hagedorn
4 weeks ago
Excellent service. Kari is wonderful. Should I move forward, I will reach out to her.
richard guevremont
4 weeks ago
Laura was great , she was prompt, professional, and kind . Also happy with the premium for my new homeowners policy . I will bundle my truck and motorcycle insurance with Laura at Cornerstone as soon as I move into our new home in Florida.
Kari M.
Jame did a awesome job in getting us placed with a new hoeowners policy on very short notice after our existing policy got non-renewed. He was prompt, efficient, friendly and courteous and got the job done! I would highly recommend him!
Erin M.
Nancy B.
Prompt response to your inquiry
Joseph P.
James did an outstanding job taking over my Home and Auto policies. He is very knowledgeable and quickly quoted both policies. I would highly recommend him!
Ms. P.
Mr. James Bonn, was quick to response, heard my needs and adjusted my policy quote to fit them. Respected my time and style of communication. I am very appreciative of the way he handled the whole process, from the sales to closing the deal.