Cornerstone Insurance

Established 2009 | Tampa, FL

Cornerstone Insurance, Inc. is a family owned-and-operated independent insurance agency founded by native Floridian and entrepreneur Joshua Butts. Josh adamantly believes clients deserve an agency that values honesty, integrity and a passion for serving others.

Core Values: honesty, integrity, professionalism, diligence and respect for our clients, fellow employees, business partners, and community.

Butts family portrait
Owner Joshua Butts and family.

Our Mission

To our clients:

To inspire faith and confidence in all we do, to provide value in the marketplace by offering quality and affordable insurance products through a choice of financially stable companies, to provide professional, timely and accurate client service, to build long lasting mutually beneficial relationships built on our core values and to become the insurance agency of choice for our target market.

To our employees:

To create a company culture where employees are respected, appreciated and valued, afforded the tools and training to be successful, to carry out our mission while emulating our core values, to create a positive and rewarding environment where team work is emphasized and efficiency and productivity are rewarded, and to offer industry competitive compensation for their valuable contributions.

To our business partners / companies:

To be a trusted, reliable and long term business partner, to write quality, mutually profitable business that will support the financial well being of our carriers and to work together to provide the best experience possible for our mutual clients.

To our community:

To invest in our community by contributing our time and financial resources, to promote and support family and country, and to be seen as a good corporate citizen operating with the highest regard for all our stakeholders.

Meet Our Team

Joshua Butts, owner

Joshua Butts

Owner
Gina McNairy

Gina McNairy

Agent
Ileana Zumbado

Ileana Zumbado

Agent
Karen Aragon

Karen Aragon

Agent
Kelley Daiker

Kelley Daiker

Agent
Kim Glowiak

Kim Glowiak

Agent
Pammie Bussey

Pammie Bussey

Agent
Beau the dog

Beau

Mascot

Why Cornerstone?

The market for Florida homeowners insurance, auto insurance, watercraft, rv etc has extreme rate and coverage option challenges unique to Florida. Many of the common brand carriers have left the state, raised premiums to an unaffordable level or reduced coverage to a point that too many exposures are not properly covered.

Cornerstone does not do business with every carrier looking to swoop in and make a quick buck. “I look for carriers with the proven ability to pay claims, do what is right by policy holders and be there should the big one hit,” says Josh Butts, owner.

“We partner with companies having years of experience in Florida specifically or with highly experienced management teams and ideally both,” Butts said. We specialize in building a package of coverage and protection around the active and sometimes complex scenarios lived out everyday by our clients.

Cornerstone Insurance is a proud member of the Florida Association of Insurance Agents, the Trusted Choice Insurance Network and an Accredited Member of the Better Business Bureau. The agency focuses exclusively on personal lines of insurance and takes pride in custom fitting a policy for the needs and desires of each client.

Cornerstone Insurance, Inc. Better Business Bureau logo and A+ rating
Trusted Choice logo

Here's What Our Clients Have to Say

Cornerstone Insurance Inc.
5.0
Based on 296 reviews
Miriam B.
Miriam B.
19:29 18 Nov 22
Joshua is very patient and quick! Made this transition effortlessly.
BeachBabeSanDiego
BeachBabeSanDiego
14:07 22 Oct 22
As a recent arrival to Florida, I really appreciate the way that Gina McNairy took me under her wing, telling me what I needed to know about insurance in Florida, and setting up the coverages that I needed.
Cynthia B.
Cynthia B.
12:31 20 Oct 22
Great service, quick to respond and worked diligently to find the right homeowner insurance and car insurance for my needs.
Vanessa W.
Vanessa W.
16:04 12 Oct 22
Great and efficient service. Fully recommend Cornerstone Insurance!
J P
J P
17:15 09 Sep 22
Excellent service! Repeat customer and I'm grateful for Gina's expert knowledge and assistance. Highly recommend.
Anastasia P.
Anastasia P.
15:59 08 Sep 22
We have been with Cornerstone for about 11 years and have always been happy. Recently we made changes to our policies and had some specific in depth and not commonly asked questions. Kelley and Josh were extremely helpful and went above and beyond to make sure we understood our exact coverages. They deal with reputable carriers and care about... their clients. Pam was and has been so responsive and kind over the years as well. I would (and have!) highly recommend this agency to anyone in the market. Icing on the cake was that they save our family about $1800/year on our insurance premiums!read more
Alex Lewis I.
Alex Lewis I.
17:11 08 Jun 22
I have worked with Cornerstone for a number of years and I’ve never been disappointed… this year has been no exception. As most people, I blindly just pay my insurance renewals without question and this year with all that is happening in the insurance world in Florida finding a company is challenge enough let alone focus on the cost. Having... someone on your side like Pammi Bussey fighting for every dollar, you can rest easy.Thanks to Pammi, not only did we secure a policy but she noticed an error in the insurance carrier’s assessment of our property which resulted in a lower premium as well as refunds from the previous years!This is the type of service you rarely see in the insurance business and I’m glad that I’m working with Cornerstone!read more
js_loader