Google Rating

5.0

Based on 484 reviews

Cornerstone Insurance Inc.

5.0

Debbie H.

1742932334

Finding good, reliable homeowners insurance in the state of Florida is not an easy task for a homeowner these days, especially if you have an older home.
Having been with the same company for over 25 years I felt overwhelmed at the thought of trying to find the right fit for us again.
Eric Bushey at Cornerstone Insurance made such an impression on myself and my husband, he was truly a pleasure to deal with.
He answered all of our questions (for many days) made suggestions, helpful ideas, and was so kind & patient with us.

Thank you Eric and Cornerstone Insurance!

Andrew P.

1742828216

Amazingly helpful. Very responsive. Highly recommend!!!

Susan T.

1742697869

I worked with James Boon at Cornerstone and he did a great job reducing our home insurance and better coverage. He was a pleasure to work with and very responsive. Highly recommend.

Jeff K.

1742684786

My goal when I first contacted Cornerstone Insurance Company was to lower my Car Insurance rates and my Home Owners Insurance rates. With the help of Agent Josh Gleaton i was able to accomplish that goal. Josh is very kind and courteous! Most importantly he is so knowledgable about the insurance industry! Personally, I felt like he was on my side! I was formally with the same company for 51 years! Honestly, they priced themselves out of what my wife and I could afford. The two companies I chose were because they are both highly rated! Josh gave me many choices. With his expertise and knowledge I was able to pick two great companies and literally save thousands of dollars a year with both policies! I might add without sacrificing one thing vs the other company I had. Actually, my car insurance deductible came down to 250.00 and my homeowners detectable went from 10% for the hurricane deductible to 2%. Anyway, call and ask for Josh Gleaton and he might be able to help you as he was able to help me! Totally, a 5 Star Company and Josh makes it easy and he’s a total gentleman!

Cynthia L.

1741986658

Eric Bushey was awesome, I'm very pleased with how he treated me and how quickly he got things done! If I could give him more stars I would.

Josh K.

1741701653

Manuel C.

1741363843

Great service and amazing price! Joshua Gleaton provided me an excellent, easy and fast service! Thank you!!!!

Nancy L.

1741282506

Called and spoke to James about my home owners insurance, he's quick, he's amazing and fast. I would like to say TY. I am now a happy customer with Cornerstone insurance.

Eric T.

1741039705

I was talking to several Insurance Companies today. Only one stood out, not because they had the best rates, but because James Bonn made it seamless. Full of knowledge and i could actually understand him on the phone. Great job James Bonn and Cornerstone

Lara P.

1740685382

James was very professional and helpful in finding the best insurance for our home .I will recommend him to all our friends.

Cyndi B.

1740176806

Eric Bushey was so quick in response & provided an excellent quote for a closing we have coming up shortly. Because I was so impressed I believe we will get our auto insurance with Cornerstone as well! Thanks Eric! the Brandons

Claude P.

1740157043

Communicating by Email is quite often frustrating and time consuming. Not so with Cornerstone Insurance; Eric bounced back my queries in no time and guided us through the process from start to finish - we're grateful for the professional service.

Tom T.

1739815140

Eric Bushey was able to quickly provide me with a quote for insurance on my condo and it was exactly what I was looking for. I highly recommend Cornerstone for your insurance needs.

Amy H.

1739460473

Kyle responded to my inquiry almost immediately and was very efficient. He saved me more than $1,000 on my homeowners policy. Thanks Kyle!

Michael L.

1739209783

Eric Bushey over at Cornerstone does an outstanding job of taking care of all my Insurance needs. His customer service and responsiveness is second to none.
I highly recommend Eric and Cornerstone.

Tracy P.

1738860334

James is extremely helpful and knowledgeable in the insurance field. He diligently worked to understand my needs and match me with the best policy. I highly recommend working with James on all your insurance needs.

D F.

1738695601

James Bonn has been a pleasure to work with! He responds promptly and is thorough in providing details. Great experience!

Elaine M.

1738091247

I had a very good experience working with Agent James Bonn.
He was able to answer any questions and always returned my call ASAP. It was a smooth transaction and also saved me money on my Homeowners Insurance . Nothing like my other agent.

Ken H.

1738085508

Just called ERIC BUSHEY with Cornerstone for an auto insurance quote because a friend had referred him to me. I didn’t expect much as I had been with my present company for several years BUT he was awesome and found me a great deal saving me almost $800/year. THANKS ERIC!!!

R & E “K” K.

1738076314

James Bonn of Cornerstone Insurance Inc is the ABSOLUTE BEST. James is ALWAYS very responsive, attentive and keeps you informed of the process. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND this company. I am a repeat customer and have FULL TRUST. THANK YOU

Johnathan B.

1738001467

I worked with licensed agent Joshua Gleaton who was super helpful, informative, prompt, and professional. He got me the best home insurance rates I could find anywhere for my new home in Sebring. Highly suggest reaching out if you have insurance needs!

Robert B.

1737752272

I got a notice in Sept 2024 that my carrier would not be renewing my policy coming up in Jan 2025 because the agent no longer represented them. I thought, "great, just what I need to shop for insurance". Then we had 2 hurricanes back to back. I sustained roof damage and knew my current provider wasn't going to cover it because my deductible was too high. So in less than 90 days I had to find a roofing contractor get a new roof installed and get inspections done all while half of Florida was doing the same thing. I managed to get the roof and inspections done by Jan 18 and started shopping insurance. On my absolute last day I had reached out to Cornerstone and Eric contacted me first thing in the morning and by mid day I was all set with a new policy with better coverage, lower deductibles and saved $800 over my previous policy!!! Super happy!

Susan C.

1737583465

Excellent work by Kim Glokk in helping me resolve the US Postal Service sending back a check that I had mailed. The post office said it was an incorrect address however I confirmed with Kim that it was the correct one. She was able to handle the payment over the phone. What a relief when it comes to home insurance that it was handled so quickly.

Gail B.

1737563255

James Bonn is such a pleasure to work with. Prompt and professional every step of the way!

Emma R.

1737147358

Cornerstone is the BEST insurance company with an amazing team. Kyle was professional, kind, and thorough. He took the time to shop through multiple carriers to find the best value and amounts of coverages to fully protect me and my family. I won't be going anywhere else for home and auto insurance!

Marisa M.

1737146109

UPDATE: My renewal came up and I was scrambling to find a new carrier as my renewal was ridiculously high. I emailed Cornerstone and had the great pleasure of working with Gina. Let me explain. It’s Friday, my HO policy expires Tuesday and Monday is a holiday. Not to mention I need a 4 point Inspection and Wind Mitigation by Tuesday. I had no hope this could be done. Gina was able to refer another contractor to do the inspections since no one was calling me back. Thanks to Gina, my inspections will be done on a Saturday, not holding up me being able to switch carriers. Cornerstone always goes above and beyond with the greatest people, Josh & Gina, thank you again!

I've been with Josh since the beginning. He's always been professional and easy to work with. When he started hiring his staff, I was a little scared to deal with anyone other than Josh, but as expected he hired great people as himself. I work with Pammie who is wonderful and will get you anything you want and gets back to you right away and takes your needs into consideration. Nick helped me out considerably with insurance on my mom's townhouse. I sent him a copy of her renewal, he called me back and was worried that she didn't have the correct coverage; therefore, not having coverage at all. He advised me to call the insurance carrier of the homes; he was correct. My mom had no coverage the previous years, he got all the paperwork done quickly so we could insure her property as soon as possible. I highly recommend Cornerstone Insurance.

Theresa M.

1736965737

Hyung K.

1736789082

James helped me get the right insurance I needed for closing in matter of few hours. Thank you for making this process so smooth.

Paola N.

1735576608

After our homeowners carrier stopped writing business in Florida we found ourselves needing a new homeowners insurance policy in two days time. James Bonn with cornerstone came to our rescue! Getting us a policy set up with a very competitive rate within a couple hours. Would definitely recommend them for all your insurance needs.

Kleber S.

1734542981

Cornerstone insurance and Gina McNairy have always provided outstanding service for my family homes and autos for more than a decade. Gina's always extremely helpful and always goes above and beyond to address my family's insurance needs. I very highly recommend Cornerstone Insurance and Gina McNairy for all of your insurance needs. They're a fantastic group!

Whitney G.

1734016982

James did a great job helping us find a homeowners policy. He walked us through all of the options, answered all of our questions promptly, and helped us get a new policy that is a substantial savings for us.

Sarah F.

1733513169

Kyle Wilson was excellent. Giving me competitive quotes with the best coverage. He is a great communicator and was easily able to explain the intricacies of the policies to me so that I understood exactly what was covered. Highly recommend!

George C.

1733414337

This isn't your typical review because I didn't end up using Cornerstone. I was working with James Bonn to find a separate insurance policy for my son's vehicle while he is in college. James discovered a way to cover my son under my existing policy which is housed with a different agent. I truly appreciated James' honesty and integrity. Thank you!

Jason M.

1733238262

We were down to the last cpl days to find suitable and affordable coverage for a home purchase. From the 1st message to proof of coverage took just a few hrs total.. we appreciate Eric for coming through!

MaryPat T.

1733231045

Kyle Wilson is my agent and helped me obtain flood insurance. He was very patient and answered all of my questions as I was new to this type of insurance. Kyle stayed in touch with me throughout the entire process. I highly recommend him!

kenzie B.

1733165835

My fiancé and I are in the process right now of buying a house and Gina has been our agent. She has gone above and beyond with giving me multiple quotes from multiple places. I called her one day when deciding and asked for her honest opinion on which quote she thought was the best since we've never done this before. She sat on the phone with us and talked us through the steps and how to read the paperwork. She was completely honest with us and I couldn't have appreciated her time more. I cannot wait to work with her again.

Nora W.

1732737282

Gina, did an excellent job. She offered to compare any other quotes I received from my own search until I feel comforter with her finding, and she was very prompt and quick to get back to me, I recommend her highly. Pleasure to work with.

james P.

1732567929

Had the pleasure talking with Eric Bushey about multiple polices. Thanks to Eric Bushey, I got a great quote on all 3 vehicles.

Gary B.

1732205900

James was the most helpfull person I have delt with on the phone in a long time. He helped me with a new policy that a different agency had issued and was canceled because of their ignorance.

Tammie C.

1732110132

I called James at Cornerstone after hurricane Milton, when we unfortunately found out our previous insurance agent did not take care of us. James was very easy to work with, answered all of my questions and made certain we had everything covered to protect us and our home, and our annual premium is $2000 less than our previous policy. I highly recommend James Bonn and Cornerstone Insurance!

Arlis C.

1731462819

James was great. He is very responsive, patient, and knowledgeable. Excellent service.

Terry C.

1730459235

Claim was handled quickly and efficiently. Loss was greater I believe,yet am happy with cornerstone

Katie B.

1730245114

James was fantastic as always. He's helped me save so much money on my home and auto insurance over the years and answers all of my questions with expertise and patience.

S P

1729804363

After having our home owners insurance nearly double, I requested several quotes from companies. Eric Bushey was quick to respond with a very reasonable rate! He is excellent at communications, very patient with all of my questions and walked me through several options we had. Eric always responds to my emails in a timely manner! I highly recommend him and Cornerstone Insurance Agency.

Kelli M.

1729098973

Prompt response. Courteous. Professional. Very highly recommend!

Kalene W.

1728930656

Great experience! James was responsive and informative and helped explain everything I needed to know to select the right coverage at a great price.

Yves N.

1728055141

James is very knowledgeable and has been very professionel in guiding us chose the correct insurances for our home. The entire process was clear, fast and very easy all the way. Our questions were answered very promptly and our concerns were taken into consideration very carefully.
Excellent follow-up!!! Highly recommending James!!!
And most... "James was very courteous".

Beth L.

1727123454

James was efficient and prompt about getting me my homeowners insurance and answering questions. Would highly recommend him! :)

Jason T.

1727117968

Eric responded right away to my questions and was able to save me a significant amount on my policy. the process was seamless.

Diane N.

1726871527

James Bonn with Cornerstone was very helpful in providing homeowner quotes. He was courteous, prompt and had my best interest at heart. I would highly recommend him as your agent and Cornerstone as the agency. Even though late Friday, James and Jamie from the office, emailed me everything needed for the new policy and cancellation of the old one. Thank you All!

Claims Information

You may now file your claim direclty online with most carriers. If you prefer to call, below are the numbers for filing or updating a claim on your policy with several carriers. If you have any questions or are unsure who to call, contact us at 1-877-277-2715 or 813-920-8181 and we are happy to walk you through it. You may also email us at [email protected] please include your name, property address and policy number if you have it available. We are here to help you!

American Integrity	1-866-277-9871
ASI/American Strategic/Progressive Home	1-866-274-5677
American Traditions	1-866-270-8430
Tower Hill Insurance	1-800-342-3407
Olympus Home Insurance	1-866-281-2242
Manatee/Safepoint Home Insurance	1-866-347-5131
Progressive Home Insurance	1-866-274-5677
Allianz	Contact Us directly at 1-877-277-2715
Markel	1-800-362-7535
Progressive Auto Insurance	1-800-776-4737
Mercury Auto Insurance	1-800-503-3724
Travelers Auto Insurance	1-800-252-4633
TAPCO	1-800-334-5579 or contact us directly at 1-877-277-2715
USLI	1-888-523-5545
RLI	1-800-444-0406
Firemans Fund	1-888-347-3428
Chubb	1-800-252-4670
GeoVera	1-800-631-6478
Modern USA	1-866-270-8430
Florida Peninsula/ Edison Home Insurance	1-866-549-9672
Universal Property & Casualty	1-800-218-3206
Slide	1-866-230-3758
Hagerty	1-800-922-4050
American Collectors	1-800-360-2277
National Risk Solutions	Contact us directly at 1-877-277-2715
Ironshore	Contact us directly at 1-877-277-2715
PersonalUmbrella.com	1-800-564-1799 or contact us directly at 1-877-277-2715
Mount Vernon Fire	1-888-523-5545
Heritage Home Insurance	1-855-415-7120

Debbie H.

Finding good, reliable homeowners insurance in the state of Florida is not an easy task for a homeowner these days, especially if you have an older home.
Having been with the same company for over 25 years I felt overwhelmed at the thought of trying to find the right fit for us again.
Eric Bushey at Cornerstone Insurance made such an impression on myself and my husband, he was truly a pleasure to deal with.
He answered all of our questions (for many days) made suggestions, helpful ideas, and was so kind & patient with us.

Thank you Eric and Cornerstone Insurance!

Andrew P.

Amazingly helpful. Very responsive. Highly recommend!!!

Susan T.

I worked with James Boon at Cornerstone and he did a great job reducing our home insurance and better coverage. He was a pleasure to work with and very responsive. Highly recommend.

Jeff K.

My goal when I first contacted Cornerstone Insurance Company was to lower my Car Insurance rates and my Home Owners Insurance rates. With the help of Agent Josh Gleaton i was able to accomplish that goal. Josh is very kind and courteous! Most importantly he is so knowledgable about the insurance industry! Personally, I felt like he was on my side! I was formally with the same company for 51 years! Honestly, they priced themselves out of what my wife and I could afford. The two companies I chose were because they are both highly rated! Josh gave me many choices. With his expertise and knowledge I was able to pick two great companies and literally save thousands of dollars a year with both policies! I might add without sacrificing one thing vs the other company I had. Actually, my car insurance deductible came down to 250.00 and my homeowners detectable went from 10% for the hurricane deductible to 2%. Anyway, call and ask for Josh Gleaton and he might be able to help you as he was able to help me! Totally, a 5 Star Company and Josh makes it easy and he’s a total gentleman!

Cynthia L.

Eric Bushey was awesome, I'm very pleased with how he treated me and how quickly he got things done! If I could give him more stars I would.