★ 4.9 · 626 Google reviews  ·  BBB A+ Accredited  ·  Trusted Choice  ·  FL agency license L061107Call or Text 813.920.8181
For Cornerstone Clients

Insurance Claims & Payments

Everything you need in one place: the verified claims phone number, online claim link, and payment portal for every carrier we represent — home, auto, flood, and umbrella. Claims are reported directly to your carrier, and payments go directly to your carrier — this page keeps every claims number, portal, and payment link in one place. Your agent’s part comes before a claim — coverage questions, deductibles, what the policy is designed to do — any quiet day at 813.920.8181.

Not sure which carrier you have? It’s on your declarations page — or just call us and we’ll look it up.

Claims & payments at a glance

Filing a claim
Report directly to your carrier — phone or online, using the verified contacts below
Making a payment
Pay your carrier directly through its portal or billing phone line, or by mail to the payment address on its card above (verified against each carrier’s own website)
Your agency
Call or text 813.920.8181 with coverage, deductible, and billing questions — the conversations that belong before a claim

Carrier phone numbers and links verified against each carrier’s official website.

★ 4.9
Google · 626 reviews
15,000+
policies written since 2009
$5B+
in Florida property insured
67
Writing in all Florida counties, one agency

How to file a claim

The fastest path to getting a claim moving is reporting it directly to your carrier — every carrier below staffs its own claims team, and many take reports around the clock by phone or online.

  • Make sure everyone is safe first. If there’s an emergency, call 911 before you call anyone about insurance.
  • Report the claim to your carrier using the phone number or online link in the directory below. Have your policy number handy — it’s on your declarations page and your ID card.
  • Document what happened. Photos and video of the damage, a list of what was affected, and receipts if you have them all help your adjuster.
  • Take reasonable steps to prevent further damage — tarping a roof opening, shutting off water at the source. Most policies ask this of you, and keeping receipts for emergency repairs matters. Hold off on permanent repairs until your adjuster has seen the damage.
  • Let the carrier’s process run. Your carrier’s adjuster handles the claim from first report to decision — keep your claim number, the adjuster’s name, and every date in one place so nothing stalls on a missing detail.
Not sure whether filing makes sense? Call or text us first at 813.920.8181 and we’ll talk it through. And after a storm, be careful with door-knocking contractors asking you to sign anything — see our guide to spotting Florida roofing scams before you sign.

Home insurance claims & payments

The 20+ Florida homeowners carriers we place. Report claims directly to your carrier by phone or online; pay through the carrier’s portal or billing line.

Claims: 800-342-3407
Pay by phone: 800-342-3407
One number for home and Tower Hill flood claims.
Mail payments to: Tower Hill Insurance Group, P.O. Box 947001, Atlanta, GA 30394-7001
Claims: 866-277-9871 24/7
Pay by phone: 866-968-8390
Hurricane/catastrophe line: 844-692-4421.
Mail payments to: American Integrity Insurance, P.O. Box 748042, Atlanta, GA 30374-8042
Claims: 866-230-3758
Pay by phone: 800-748-2030
Pay by phone: 800-748-2030.
Mail payments to: the remittance address printed on your Slide bill (Slide publishes it per policy); pay online or at 800-748-2030
Claims: 800-470-0599
One-time guest payment available without a login.
Mail payments to: Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company, P.O. Box 88763, Chicago, IL 60680-1763
Claims: 866-549-9672
Pay by phone: 877-229-2244
Mail payments to: Dept #6641, Florida Peninsula Insurance Company, P.O. Box 11407, Birmingham, AL 35246-6641
Claims: 888-683-7971
Pay by phone: 866-568-8922
Mail payments to: Dept #6642, Edison Insurance Company, P.O. Box 11407, Birmingham, AL 35246-6642
Claims: 888-247-0486
Pay by phone: 888-247-0482
Water-damage claim hotline: 888-450-3119. Payments by phone or through the member portal (Login on ovationhome.com).
Mail payments to: Dept #6643, Ovation Home Insurance Exchange, P.O. Box 11407, Birmingham, AL 35246-6643
Claims: 855-415-7120
Pay by phone: 855-536-2744
855-415-7120 files a new claim; 855-536-2744 reaches claims reps and billing.
Mail payments to: Heritage Property & Casualty Insurance Company, P.O. Box 71111, Charlotte, NC 28272-1111 (dwelling-fire, wind-only and mobile home policies: c/o The Bank of Tampa, P.O. Box 22007, Tampa, FL 33622-2007)
Claims: 877-333-9992
Mail payments to: Security First Insurance Company, P.O. Box 916056, Orlando, FL 32891-6056
Claims: 866-281-2242
Mail payments to: Olympus Insurance, P.O. Box 15001, Worcester, MA 01615
Claims: 877-900-2280
NFIP flood policies through Southern Oak: 800-725-9472.
Mail payments to: Southern Oak Insurance, P.O. Box 45-9020, Sunrise, FL 33345-9020
Claims: 800-293-2532
Claims line staffed Mon–Fri 9–5; claims can be started online anytime.
Mail payments to: Monarch National Ins Co., P.O. Box 15138, Worcester, MA 01615
Trident Reciprocal Exchange
Claims: 877-368-9144 24/7
Mailing address: Trident Reciprocal, P.O. Box 950699, Lake Mary, FL 32795 (check your bill for a separate remittance address)
Claims: 866-347-5131 24/7
Flood claims: 888-598-0446.
Mail payments to: Manatee Insurance Exchange, P.O. Box 290959, Tampa, FL 33687
Claims: 866-270-8430
Policy service runs through Jerger, ATIC’s administrator — that’s the official claims site.
Mail payments to: American Traditions Insurance Co., P.O. Box 830856, Philadelphia, PA 19182-0856
US Coastal Property & Casualty
Claims: 866-482-5246 24/7
Serviced by Cabrillo Coastal; claims handled by Harbor Claims.
Mail payments to: Cabrillo Coastal General Insurance Agency, P.O. Box 357966, Gainesville, FL 32635-7966
Orange Insurance Exchange
Claims: 866-896-7233
Serviced by Cabrillo Coastal; online claim form available around the clock.
Mailing address: Orange Insurance Exchange, P.O. Box 140250, Gainesville, FL 32614-0250 (check your bill for the remittance address)
Safe Harbor Insurance
Claims: 866-482-5246 24/7
Serviced by Cabrillo Coastal — same claims line as US Coastal.
Mail payments to: Cabrillo Coastal General Insurance Agency, P.O. Box 357966, Gainesville, FL 32635-7966
SafePoint Insurance
Claims: 866-347-5131 24/7
Flood claims: 888-598-0446.
Mail payments to: SafePoint Insurance, P.O. Box 292547, Tampa, FL 33687
Claims: 866-274-5677
ASI now operates as Progressive Home — file and pay through your Progressive account.
Mail payments to: the remittance address printed on your Progressive bill; Progressive does not publish a single payment box
Claims: 877-700-3727 24/7
Billing questions: 877-700-3727
Payments by mail: Mangrove Managing Agency, LLC, P.O. Box 5130, Deptford, NJ 08096 (standard mail only). Losses from before a Citizens assumption date go to Citizens.

Auto insurance claims & payments

Our auto carriers all take claims around the clock — report by phone or through the carrier’s app or website.

Progressive
Claims: 800-776-4737 24/7
One number for claims, service, and payments.
Mail payments to: the remittance address printed on your Progressive bill; it varies by billing center
GEICO
Claims: 800-841-3000 24/7
Pay by phone: 800-932-8872
Mail payments to: GEICO Remittance Center, P.O. Box 70776, Philadelphia, PA 19176-0776 (late or cancellation-notice payments: P.O. Box 70775, Philadelphia, PA 19176-0775)
Travelers
Claims: 800-252-4633 24/7
Pay by phone: 888-564-5043
One-time payment available without a login.
Mail payments to: Travelers Personal Insurance, P.O. Box 660307, Dallas, TX 75266-0307
Safeco / Liberty Mutual
Claims: 800-225-2467 24/7
Pay by phone: 800-290-8711
Safeco policies are serviced under Liberty Mutual — one claims center for both.
Mail payments to: Liberty Mutual Insurance Group, Personal Market – RPC, P.O. Box 1604, New York, NY 10116-1604 (use the address on your bill if it differs)
Mercury Insurance
Claims: 800-503-3724 24/7
Same number reaches claims (around the clock) and billing.
Mail payments to: Mercury does not publish a payment box; pay online, by phone at 800-503-3724, or to the address on your bill
Foremost
Claims: 800-527-3907 24/7
Pay by phone: 800-532-4221
Our go-to for many mobile and manufactured home policies.
Mail payments to: Foremost Insurance Group, P.O. Box 0915, Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915

Flood insurance claims & payments

Flood is a separate policy from homeowners — even when the same storm causes both kinds of damage, the flood claim is reported to your flood carrier. If your flood policy is through the NFIP, your declarations page names the insurance company that services it; that’s who takes the claim.

Neptune Flood
Claims: 727-202-4815 24/7
Neptune places your policy with a backing insurer — report to Neptune and they route it.
Mail payments to: the address printed on your Neptune invoice; Neptune recommends paying through its portal
NFIP flood policies
Claims: 877-336-2627
NFIP claims are filed with the insurance company named on your flood declarations page. Can’t find it? The NFIP help center at 877-336-2627 can locate your insurer.
Mail payments to: your NFIP servicing company at the address on your renewal bill; the NFIP itself has no single payment address

Umbrella & specialty claims

Umbrella claims usually start with the underlying home or auto claim — report that first, then notify your umbrella carrier. Call us if you’re not sure your umbrella carrier should be notified; erring on the side of notifying is the safe move.

RLI (personal umbrella)
Claims: 800-444-0406
Pay by phone: 866-302-7925
Umbrella claims are reported through RLI’s online claim form; the number reaches the general claims team.
Mail payments to: RLI Insurance Company, Dept 3300, P.O. Box 779018, Chicago, IL 60677-9018 (payments line 866-216-8009)
USLI
Claims: 888-523-5545
Pay by phone: 866-632-2003
Choose option 3 for claims; after-hours emergency claim line: 888-875-5231.
Mail payments to: the address on your USLI invoice; USLI takes payments online at myaccount.usli.com and by phone

Making a payment

Premium payments go directly to your insurance carrier, not to our agency — that keeps your payment posted to your policy the moment the carrier receives it.

The fastest ways to pay:

  • Online — use the “Pay / policy login” link on your carrier’s card above. Many carriers offer a one-time payment option; others handle payments through the policyholder portal.
  • By phone — call the carrier’s billing number on your invoice or declarations page.
  • Through escrow — if your homeowners premium is escrowed, your mortgage servicer pays the carrier directly from your escrow account. If you receive a bill and believe your lender should be paying it, call us before the due date and we’ll help you sort out who’s paying.
Worried about a due date or a cancellation notice? Don’t wait — call or text us at 813.920.8181 right away. The sooner we know, the more options you have.

What your agent does before a claim

Your claim is handled and decided by your carrier’s adjuster — the filing, the inspection, and the decision all run through the carrier. Your agent’s work comes earlier: making sure you understand what your policy provides and how the process works, where your deductibles sit, and whether a loss is even worth filing — in plain English, before anything happens. After the claim closes, we’ll review your coverage with you so the policy still fits the way you live.

If a claim doesn’t go the way you expected, start with our guide on what to do when a home insurance claim is denied in Florida — then call us.

After the claim: repairs, proof, and your next renewal

A claim isn’t fully over when the check clears. Before the next renewal is offered, carriers generally want evidence that the damage has actually been repaired — contractor invoices, permits, photos of the finished work. That’s not a penalty; an insurer re-signing a policy wants to know the home is whole again, and a tidy repair file is what makes the renewal routine.

Florida law sets the clock here, and it runs in your favor. Nonrenewing a residential policy takes at least 120 days’ advance written notice under s. 627.4133, Florida Statutes — and when the damage came from a hurricane or windstorm under a declared emergency, the same statute bars cancellation or nonrenewal until 90 days after the property has been repaired. For other covered losses, the protection runs until the repairs are complete or one year after the final claim payment, whichever comes first. The statute keeps a few exceptions — nonpayment, claim-related misstatements, and repairs the homeowner unreasonably delays — so steady, documented progress is exactly what preserves the protection.

The habit that pays: when your carrier asks for proof of repairs, send it promptly and keep copies in the same folder as your claim number and adjuster notes. And a post-claim renewal is still a renewal — working with your agent, it’s worth setting that offer beside the rest of the market before you sign for another year.

Claims & payments FAQs

Should I call my agent or my carrier first when something happens?

The claim itself is filed with your carrier — online or through its claims line — and that’s doubly true when damage is serious or it’s after hours: the claims line is staffed for exactly that, and many carriers take reports around the clock. If you’re unsure whether what happened is worth a claim, call or text us first at 813.920.8181 and we’ll talk it through before anything is filed.

Will filing a claim raise my home insurance rate?

A prior claim doesn’t raise your property insurance rate the way a ticket raises an auto rate. What it actually does is limit carrier eligibility — some carriers won’t quote a home with recent claims, which can cost you access to the lowest-priced markets — and it typically costs you the claims-free discount, which generally runs 2–10%. That’s exactly why it’s worth a conversation with us before filing a small claim.

What information do I need to file a claim?

Your policy number (on your declarations page or ID card), the date and a plain description of what happened, photos or video if you have them, and a callback number. Don’t hold off on reporting because you’re missing something — carriers can open the claim and collect details as you go.

How does my hurricane deductible work on a claim?

Florida hurricane deductibles are a percentage of your dwelling coverage (Coverage A), not a percentage of the claim. Florida law requires insurers to offer deductible options of $500, 2%, 5%, or 10% of the dwelling limit — so a 2% deductible on a $400,000 dwelling limit is $8,000, no matter the size of the loss. Your declarations page shows the percentage you chose. If you’re not sure what yours is, send us your dec page and we’ll go through it with you.

My home and flood damage came from the same storm. Is that one claim?

No — homeowners and flood are separate policies, often with different carriers, and each claim is reported separately. Wind-related damage is reported under your homeowners policy; rising-water damage is reported under your flood policy, and each claim is adjusted under that policy’s own terms. When both happen at once, report both promptly and tell each adjuster the other claim exists. We can help you keep the two straight.

Can I make my payment through your office?

Payments are made directly to your carrier — online, by phone, or through your mortgage escrow. That’s the industry standard, and it protects you: your payment posts to your policy the moment the carrier receives it. What we can do is help you find the right portal, sort out an escrow mix-up, or get ahead of a cancellation notice — call or text 813.920.8181.

Will my carrier renew my policy after a claim?

Usually — but expect a request for proof of repairs first. Carriers commonly make the next renewal contingent on evidence that the damage is fixed: invoices, permits, photos. Florida gives you room to get it done — nonrenewal of a residential policy requires at least 120 days’ written notice, and under s. 627.4133 a carrier can’t cancel or nonrenew a home damaged by a hurricane or windstorm under a declared emergency until 90 days after the repairs are complete (for other covered losses, until the home is repaired or one year after the final claim payment, whichever comes first). Exceptions exist for nonpayment, claim-related misstatements, and repairs that are unreasonably delayed — so keep the work moving and the paperwork together, and send proof the moment it’s requested.

Rather talk it through with a person?

Real agents, the best carriers, and technology that makes it easy.
Theresa M.
Kyle is excellent to work with!
Sharon G.
We worked with Laura Litchy who was extremely helpful and knowledgable, answering our many questions and providing us with several options from which to choose. In addition she went out of her way to make sure we contacted the fire Marshall about upgrading our home’s fire protection rating which saved us several hundred dollars. We look forward to working with Laura and Cornerstone, our new Homeowners insurance agency.
SUSAN P.
Very professional and very knowledgeable. Laura was able to get the best quote possible that fit our needs. I highly recommend Cornerstone Insurance Agency.
TACO D.
Kari handle all of my work and no issues. Needed insurance and gave me great deal.
Paula S.
Kari handled my request for a quote very well! She was professional and kind. I wish her quote was less but I will review it again in early ‘27 when I renew my homeowners policy.